The Best Organic Nipple Creams to Relieve Breast Pain

The Best Organic Nipple Creams to Relieve Breast Pain

Hi, Mama.

Are your nipples sore, cracked, or (worse) bleeding? I bet you never envisioned having bleeding nipples when you signed up for breastfeeding. You’re not the only one, I promise. When my nipples were at their worst, every mom and her grandma recommended lanolin.

The Best Organic Nipple Creams to Relieve Breast Pain

Tacky, stain-your-favorite-nursing-bra, sheep wax, lanolin. Ugh!

I’m not going to do that to you, Mama. You need results—like, yesterday—and a product that is safe, right? So, we’re getting straight into the best organic nipple creams on the market. Let’s get crackin’!

…pun not intended.

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase from one of the links I will make a small commission at no charge to you. I only recommend what I trust.

The Best Organic Nipple Creams: Why is Organic Better?

Technically, some lanolin products could be organic. Lanolin is actually extracted from sheep’s wool; it’s the wax that coats the sheep’s wool to repel water and dirt. When lanolin is extracted, it goes through a very hefty purification process. Most pesticides used to protect the sheep from fleas and mites, should be removed in the process. Most.

Lanolin is pretty safe—I’m not going to tell you otherwise. Plenty of moms and babies have used this product without a single hiccup. However, the issue is, there are trace amounts of pesticides found in lanolin. In addition, many lanolin products have several added chemicals. So, while lanolin certainly isn’t the devil, for the health-conscious mama, the thought of our little one ingesting even a fragment of chemical residue may be too much.

Not to mention, why purchase a product that contains controversial ingredients, doesn’t work as well (from my experience), and makes a super mess?

What Makes The Best Organic Nipple Creams


Safe Ingredients

Almost every nipple cream advertises that it is safe for your baby to ingest in small amounts. However, with trace amounts of pesticides in lanolin, I found myself washing my nipples more often than not. Just in case.

But come on! Your nipples are already dry as it is. There’s no way you should subject yourself to unnecessary pain. When you wash your nipples before each nursing session, you’re actually irritating them further.

The best solution is to find a product with ingredients that you 100% trust.


Breastfeeding should be an enjoyable experience for you and your baby. When you dread every single session, you’re missing out on a precious part of motherhood. While choosing the the best organic nipple cream for you, keep in mind the ingredients. Invest in one that will relieve your pain fast.


The Texture

There are nipple creams and nipple balms. Some women prefer the light texture of cream while other women prefer a little more substance. Personally, my biggest complaint with lanolin was the tacky texture. It was a gooey mess that was a little difficult to distribute.

Whichever type of product you choose, you want as little contact as possible, with the smallest amount of cream/balm as possible.


I guess this is a given. When you’re spending all of your hard-earned cash on diapers and assorted baby gear, let’s face it…there’s not much left over for you. Some nipple creams are expensive—but when I compared them to a few other creams, I honestly couldn’t tell you why. Sometimes products are overpriced, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re better. So, I tried to make sure that every item on this list has great value.

The 5 Best Organic Nipple Cream to Relieve Sore Breasts

1: Motherlove Nipple Cream

Motherlove Nipple Cream is at the top of my best organic nipple creams list. If you’ve read any of my breastfeeding-related posts, you’ve probably heard me sing praises for this product. That’s because it saved me. During the first two weeks of motherhood, I didn’t have Motherlove Nipple Cream.  I used lanolin religiously and grew so frustrated with the lack of results. It was one of the biggest newbie mistakes I made. I’m so glad I wizened up. This cream is affordable, it feels great, and it works super fast. The texture was light (so light that at first I doubted its efficiency) and refreshing.

The ingredients truly make this cream excellent. The main ingredients, marshmallow root and calendula flower, not only soften your dry, cracked skin, but actively work to heal the wounds.

Here’s Motherlove Nipple Cream in a nutshell:


  • USDA-Approved Organic
  • No GMO
  • All-natural ingredients, such as shea butter, beeswax, extra virgin olive oil, calendula flower, and marshmallow root, which is one of the ingredients found in their pregnancy belly salve.


  • 1 ounce bottle

2: Mommy know’s Best soothing Nipple Cream

MotherLove and Mommy Knows Best are names that inspire brand-loyalty in mommies. If you’ve been using Mommy Knows Best breastfeeding products so far and you feel a little brand-loyalty, then go ahead and stick with this product. It’s a great nipple cream and it has hundreds of reviews to prove it. Like MotherLove, this nipple cream is USDA Organic-Approved, American-made, and contains absolutely none of the fishy elements that lanolin brands carry. Plus, the Mommy Know’s Best Nipple Cream also contains Vitamin E, which makes it an excellent side-treatment for eczema.

Also, keep in mind that this comes in a larger container, which translates to a better bang for your buck.


  • USDA-Approved Organic
  • Non GMO
  • 2 oz container
  • All-natural ingredients such as, cocoa butter, olive oil, aloe extract, vitamin e, mango, sunflower oil, beeswax, and more.
  • Can be used for other afflictions, such as chapped lips and eczema.


  • Vitamin E is a slightly controversial ingredient for a baby to ingest

[mailerlite_form form_id=9]

3: Bamboobies Boob-ease Organic Nipple Cream

You’ve gotta admit, this is a super catchy name. If you’re not familiar with Bamboobies, they are a manufacturer that dominates in the nursing market. They make nursing bras, heating pads, washable breastpads, breast pump lubricant (I wish I had known that had existed 6 months ago!), and other goodies.

The Bamboobies Organic Nipple Cream (Cleverly called, Boob-ease) is a little higher-priced than the MotherLove and Mommy Knows Best products, but you’re purchasing a product from a great brand, with a super trendy name, and absolutely stellar customer reviews.


  • USDA-Approved Organic
  • No GMO
  • All-natural ingredients such as, cocoa butter, olive oil, marshmallow root, calendula flower, shea butter, beeswax.

1 oz container is higher priced than other options

4: Earth Mama Organic Nipple Butter

If you prefer a thicker balm with a little more substance, the Earth Mama Organic Nipple Butter might be for you. It has a unique gritty texture (plant butters) that quickly melts into a soothing oil. It contains the usual suspects, such as sunflower seed oil, olive oil, calendula flower, beeswax, shea butter, cocoa butter, and a nice addition of mango seed oil.

The only downside to this product is the price, which is a little higher for a 2 oz. bottle. Keep in mind that an extra dollar won’t break the bank as long as you enjoy the texture.


  • USDA-Approved Organic
  • Non GMO
  • All-Natural Ingredients (See above)
  • Thicker, balm texture
  • 2 oz.


  • Thicker, balm texture (if you don’t like that)
  • More expensive

5: Upspring All-Natural Nipple Balm

Upspring produces a lot of high-quality organic products, such as lactation-friendly herb supplements and drink mixers. They are a great manufacturer, so it makes total sense that they would also create one of the best organic nipple creams on the market. Technically speaking, this cream is actually a balm. This product is pretty unique among the other items on this list. It’s base is coconut oil—my stretch mark savior during the pregnancy days. Coconut oil is loaded with vitamins that pack a powerful healing punch. Just keep in mind the texture—some women despise rubbing any thick ointment on their breasts.

If you’re looking for the best value, then the Upspring All-Natural Nipple Balm http://amzn.to/2Gs0ppM is your product. It’s the perfect substitute for lanolin cream—very similar texture, closer price point, and better ingredients.


  • USDA-Approved Organic
  • No GMO
  • All-natural ingredients—the base product is coconut oil. It also has additional ingredients, such as beeswax, sunflower seed oil, rosemary seed extract, shea butter, and calendula flower.
  • Has a slightly coconut-y scent
  • Excellent price-point


  • Thick texture can be irritating for application


The Winner of the Best Organic Nipple Creams is…

Maybe I’m just biased, but when I look at overall value, the Motherlove Nipple Cream seems to check off all the boxes. It’s inexpensive, the texture is light, a little dab goes a long way, and it’s manufactured from a trusted brand. Having said that, all of these products are definitely some of the best organic nipple creams on the market. You just need to decide what kind of texture you favor and how much nipple cream you’d like to purchase.

Just a final word, Mama. If you’re struggling with nipple pain, there is NO reason why you shouldn’t seek out relief. Every product on this list is trustworthy and just a day’s shipping away. Take care of you so you can happily take care of your baby.

Remember, the number one cause of sore nipples is a bad latch. Work on correcting that, first and foremost. If you continue to have a problem. I would not hesitate to visit a lactation consultant. You may be struggling with an overactive let-down (I know how that goes!) or your baby could have a tongue tie (and I know all about that as well!). Treat the symptoms but never forget about the disease!

Good luck, Mama! Please let me know how it goes and tell me what YOU think some of the best organic nipple creams are in the comments below.

Related Articles:

 Breastfeeding a Tongue Tied Baby

The Secret to Breastfeeding With an Overactive Letdown

The Best Organic Nipple Creams - Breast Pain Relief

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept the Privacy Policy